Camera Review: Nikon S2 with Nikkor-S 50mm f/1.4

Posted on by Bellamy


Camera review: Nikon S2 with Nikkor-S 50mm f/1.4
A great review from guest writer Leonard Goh. The S2 is a classic rangefinder that is a great experience to use. Let’s let Leonard tell us about it.

Review: Nikon S2 with Nikkor-S 50mm f/1.4

Opening note: While I have been lurking about this site for a very long time, and wish that I could buy something from Bellamy, I haven’t done so. Feeling a tad guilty about it, I decided to reciprocate by writing a review of the Nikon S2, which I find to be a truly amazing rangefinder camera.

The Nikon S2 is the Japanese company’s best-selling, and most-produced rangefinder camera with approximately 56,000 pieces rolling out of the factory since its inception in 1955. The S2 succeeded the Nikon S, which was fundamentally built upon the early Contax rangefinder cameras, so much so that even the lens mounts between the two systems are the same.

Like most rangefinder cameras built during that era, the Nikon S2 has a solid heft to it, and you could tell that an amazing effort was put into making the S2 a “tank”. It has an almost full-metal construction, save for the use of plastic for some components such as the skin of the camera.

The top deck of the Nikon is rather minimalist. The shutter speed dial is split into two layers. The one at the top is reserved for faster shutter speeds, while the one below it is meant for speeds that is 1/30th of a second or slower. In order to activate the slower shutter speeds, you will need to turn the top dial to 1/30. This may seem cumbersome by some, but it’s only a matter of getting used to. I found it really easy to adapt.

The hotshoe has no contact points, and is mainly for fixing a flash unit that can be connected to the X-sync port located on the left of the shooter.

Some features of the Nikon S2 later made their debut in Nikon’s first SLR, the Nikon F. For example, the removable back of the camera to load film, as well as the A/R (advance or rewind) collar that surrounds the shutter button.

Focusing can be done via two methods. Either turning the lens manually, or you can also spin the toothed wheel that is at the front of the camera. This is commonly known as helical focusing, which means the lens is rotated to focus via the camera body, and the lens elements don’t rotate to focus. This is great for one handed operation of the camera (only when you have the shutter speed and aperture fixed), since you can hold the camera up to your eye, focus and click the shutter button all with one hand. For a man who’s holding his wife’s shopping bags like me, it’s a god-send.

The 1:1 viewfinder is also wonderful for focusing with both eyes opened, something which even modern rangefinder lacks. One thing to note, however, is that the Nikon S2 viewfinder windows provides a 50mm field-of-view with no framelines for lenses of other focal length. So, if you attach a 35mm lens on it, you will definitely need an external optical viewfinder.

One little rant I’ll like to make with regards to the S2 is the fact that you need to manually reset the film counter when you load a new roll of film. Also, if you are thinking that the S2′s shutter sound will be silent like Leicas, you’ll be wrong. While it’s not as loud as a SLR, the S2′s shutter is definitely noticeable and jarring in a quiet environment.

There is no exposure meter on the S2, so you can either use the Voigtlander VCII meter or like me, who uses Tri-X, gauge the exposure values required.

All in, the S2 is a great body if you are looking to acquire a Nikon rangefinder camera. However, it may be tough to find one is a good working and exterior condition. Bellamy is selling off his personal set, too, and I’m sure he won’t be selling a banged up unit. Lenses are pretty scarce these days, but I’m sure Bellamy can source for a few nice pieces. I’m looking to get a 35mm for it in months to come.

The Nikkor-S 50mm f/1.4
The Nikkor-S 50mm f/1.4 is a lovely contrasty lens. I am not able to comment on its color reproduction, since I have only shot with B/W film with it so far. The copy that I have is almost flawless optically, and visual inspection shows that the coating is still on. The lens is a tad contrasty, but the sharpness is unbelievable for an optics that is so old. While I won’t go to the extent and say that it is sharper than a Leica Summilux-M 50mm of the same era, it is definitely comparable. The “bokeh” on the Nikkor-S 50mm f/1.4 however, isn’t as smooth as a Leica, but I am sure this won’t be an issue for most people.

It has a 43mm front diameter, so getting filters and generic lens cap for it might be a problem. I managed to sourced for mine in Hong Kong at good prices. The construction of the lens, like the body, is a solid piece of work.

I have read online that the Contax lenses can be used for the Nikon S2 as well, though some lenses won’t be able to focus accurately due to the different construction. Voigtlander issued some Nikon S lenses a few years ago, but has since discontinued it. It may be hard to find additional lenses for your Nikon S rangefinder camera, but I’m quite sure there are many great units in Japan that Bellamy can find for you.

Parting note: It’s been a long time since I used a camera that made me fall in love with taking photographs again, but the Nikon S2 with the Nikkor-S 50mm f/1.4 did it. Solid construction of the body and lens, together with relatively user-friendly operation makes this a great shooter especially if you are into Nikon rangefinder cameras.

About Leonard Goh
Leonard is a business manager for a German camera manufacturer, and is based in Singapore. He shot for Singapore’s largest English papers, and has also done editorial and commercial work before stepping into the corporate world when he realized that he would rather keep his passion for photography and putting bread on the table separately. You can follow him on Twitter at http://twitter.com/gohleonard or find him on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/leonardgoh

Images are courtesy of Leonard Goh and may not be used or reproduced without permission.
Thanks
Japancamerahunter

3 Responses to Camera Review: Nikon S2 with Nikkor-S 50mm f/1.4

Jon October 3, 2012 at 1:04 pm

Nice review! Great to see other people out there using Nikon rangefinders. If you don’t mind, allow me to provide a little more detail on a few things you mentioned :-)

* Due to their external appearance and lens mount, it’s often said that Nikon rangefinders are based on Contax rangefinders, but the innards are actually more similar to a Leica rangefinder than a Contax rangefinder. The story goes that Nikon engineers copied what they thought was the best technology at the time, so chose a mount similar to the Contax rangefinders (but not the same – more on that in a moment) and a shutter and brake mechanism similar to the Leica rangefinder design. The result is that there are no unreliable Contax-like “venetian curtain” shutters to be found in a Nikon rangefinder, just very reliable horizontal traveling cloth shutter curtains. One improvement that the Nikon engineers did make to the shutter mechanism compared to Leica, is the inclusion of dry bearings for the shutter drums. The result is that Nikon rangefinders rarely need speed adjustments or a CLA even after sitting unused for months or years. They just keep on ticking.

* One often finds that despite being 50 plus years old, the lens coatings of the vintage rangefinder Nikkors are still in very good condition compared to lens from other manufacturers of the same period. The reason is that Nikon already had very high quality hard glass coating technology developed for harsh environments such as for submarine perescopes, so Nikon continued to use that technology when they switched to making lenses.

* Lastly, there’s a lot of just plain bad information about the difference between the Contax mount and Nikon mount out there on the internet, so here’s a quick summary of the difference. While they look similar and operate the same, there is a difference between the mounts that prevents lenses from one system being used seamlessly on the other system.

- Firstly, the register (distance from lens mount to film plane) at infinity is the same for both Contax and Nikon so all lenses will focus properly at any aperture on either system’s camera *when set to infinity*.

- The pitch of the focus helicoid is the same for both Nikon and Contax, so the distance the lens moves away from the film plane is the same for both systems IF the lens is rotated the same amount of degrees.

Now here’s the difference that causes all the confusion!

* The Nikon mount is designed for the Leica standard lens of 51.6mm, so rotates about 260 degrees to focus a lens from infinity to 0.90m (minimum focus).

But the Contax mount is designed for a standard lens of 52.4mm, so rotates about 270 degrees to focus a lens from infinity to 0.90m (minimum focus).

This extra 10 degrees of rotation by the Contax rangefinder mount places the lens about 0.1mm further away from the film plane at minimum focus compared to a Nikon rangefinder. Great if you have a 52.4mm standard lens, but with a 51.6mm lens you get front focus. About 10cm of front focus to be precise.

This slight discrepancy is why when you focus from infinity to minimum focus distance, ALL Nikon rangefinder lenses progressively tend towards worse front focus on a Contax rangefinder, and Contax lenses progressively tend towards worse back focus on a Nikon rangefinder. All lenses in both systems lock into the mount on the camera to transmit the amount of rotation when focused, so this focus error occurs for all lenses including both internal mount and external mount lenses regardless of focal length.

However, all is not lost! The conventional wisdom is that the focus error is covered by DOF with 35mm f2.5 lens and wider focal lengths and/or slower maximum apertures, so wide angle lenses can be used freely between the systems without having to worry about focus accuracy. However, you start to see focus errors with 50mm lenses at close distances and wide apertures, and the focus errors get worse as the focal length increases. So telephoto lenses are a no-no, but you can probably get by with a 50mm lens from the other system on your camera at close distances if you’re prepared to stop it down a little. Hope that helps!

Reply
Leonard October 3, 2012 at 4:50 pm

wow! Thanks,Jon, for the added info. I didnt know about the harsh mechanics behind the contax and nikon till you mentioned it!

Reply
    Jon October 4, 2012 at 4:38 pm

    Hi Leonard, have you tried shooting your Nikkor-S 5cm f/1.4 at f/1.4? At f/1.4 the contrast is fairly low and images have a nice “Nikkor glow” to them. Perfect for portraits. The glow pretty much goes away completely and contrast goes up when the lens is stopped down about half a stop, so the lens actually has a bit of a split personality.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

© Copyright 2014 Japan Camera Hunter, all rights reserved. Template by HK. Design updated and maintained by Ashkas Design